Sarah’s a Member of the Chicago Film Critics Association

Chicago Film Critics Association

Sarah Knight-Adamson writes for TribLocal

Sarah’s the Regional Arts
and Entertainment
Columnist for TribLocal
a subsidiary of The
Chicago Tribune. Her
articles appear online
and weekly in print.
Trib Local

Follow Sarah...

Facebook Twitter YouTube Podcast
Moe Joe's Cajun and Caribbean Cuisine Restaurant Review 
 | Print |
Restaurant Reviews - Reviews: Chicago and Suburbs
Alligator Fricassee Photo Credit: Sarah Adamson
Alligator Fricassee Photo Credit: Sarah Adamson

MoeJoe’s Cajun and Caribbean Cuisine Restaurant Review
510 Lockport St.
Plainfield, Illinois
(815) 230-2790
Hours: 11am - 1am Monday through Thursday
11am - 2am Friday and Saturday
Noon - midnight Sunday

The Scoop- Total Dining Experience: ★★★ out of 4

Here’s a hidden gem of a place if you’re looking for authentic cajun upscale food. We’d go back, due to the food preparation, service, New Orleans atmosphere, attention to details and location (downtown Plainfield).

Favorite item we tried − ‘Alligator Fricassee’. Forget about booking a flight to New Orleans. With a menu that features alligator fricassee, turtle soup, crawfish etouffee, jambalaya and Southern-fried frog legs, MoeJoe's Cajun and Caribbean Cuisine is a lot closer to home and just as good as anything you'll find in the French Quarter.

If you decide to experience this downtown Plainfield eatery, save room for a final course. Dessert lovers will be in "voodoo heaven" after sampling the homemade beignets and bourbon chocolate ganache cheesecake. We certainly were.

Stopping by on a Friday evening, we were in for a pleasant surprise. Not only did every dish we try practically jump off the plate with flavor, the presentation was equally spectacular.

The restaurant's decor is pure New Orleans theme, complete with lamp posts, wrought-iron fencing, Mardi Gras beads and glass lanterns. It's impossible not to get in the groove and almost forget you aren't, in fact, in New Orleans (the only reminder were the snowflakes visible through the front window). We put on the shiny colorful beads we were given and proceeded to enjoy the evening. The decor is causal and families were also present.

Yum Factor − Details of the items we tried.

Alligator Fricassee − hands down, the hit of the evening and a rare menu item, not just for the Chicago area but the entire northern region of the country. You’re probably thinking, "Oh I’ve had alligator before and it tastes like chicken." That may be, but this cut of alligator comes from the under belly and tastes nothing like chicken. Are you ready for this? The texture is like pork tenderloin and the taste is similar to white fish. The fricassee sauce featured a white roux, rice, carrot slices, peas, celery and parsley. $17

If you aren’t the adventurous type, no worries. MoeJoe’s offers plenty of other options, including burgers, steaks, pork chops, sandwiches and fish.

Catfish−grilled to perfection; flaky and melt-in-your-mouth good. A choice of two sides come with dinner entrees. We went with the red beans and buttery flavored rice. $13

Shrimp Kabobs − appetizer was a solid choice to start out dinner. It was served on sugar cane skewers, a nice twist, and the shrimp were large, fresh and delicate, not tough by any means. The pineapple chutney it was served with was a perfect pairing in my book. $10

Quarter Hurricane Drink−a great mix of rum and fruit juices served in a tall whimsical glass decorated with Mardi Gras beads. Mixed drinks have creative names: Gummy Bear Martini, Sweet Tart Martini, Razzitini.

Desserts were memorable and we enjoyed both choices equally.

Beignets (pronounced ben-yays) − are similar to the elephant ears you'll find at carnivals and fairs. They're deep-fried and covered in powdered sugar, and the ones served at MoeJoe's may be the best I’ve tasted anywhere, and that’s includes those I've sampled on numerous visits to New Orleans. Homemade and served hot, they were light and not greasy.

Chocolate Ganache Cheesecake − with an Oreo cookie crumb crust and caramel sauce drizzle. This is not your typical Eli’s fare -- there's no mistaking that it's homemade because they've got light and creamy texture down to perfection.

We saw families dining (they offer a children’s menu) as well as couples and groups. At 10 p.m., they clear away the tables to make way for dancing and entertainment. Live bands are brought in and a DJ spins most weekends.

Backstage Notes: I’ve eaten in New Orleans, Louisiana on several occasions and enjoyed the experience tremendously. My experience were with some rather high end places and a few average priced. The famous Brennan’s is known for their Bananas Foster and I actually have a signed cook book from the chef. Another memorable restaurant is The Court of Two Sisters. I tasted alligator at a local eatery on Bourbon Street and wasn’t impressed as it did taste rather tough and somewhat like chicken. Same held true for frogs legs.

Cajun refers to French Acadians that settled from Canada in the South. Creole refers to descendants of France, Spain and those of mixed nationalities in the Caribbean. The restaurant decor was a little causal and dimly lit for my liking and the very casual bar next door opens to fairly loud music at times. We were told remodeling plans were in the works.

Website: www.eatmoejoes.com

Restaurant Review Guide

★★★★ Highest of all areas. (Quality of Food, Location, Service, Atmosphere)

 

★★★½ Food is excellent, 1 or 2 other areas lacking

 

★★★ Food is very good, 1 or 2 other areas lacking

 

★★ Food is average, several other areas lacking

 

★½ Food is good, several other areas lacking

 

★ All areas need help

 

Sarah Adamson© January 20, 2011

 

Listen to Sarah’s Film Reviews and Celebrity Interviews on WIND AM560 Hollywood 360 Radio Show

Hollywood 360
Broadcast Saturday Night
8:05pm-8:25pm CST Reviews
9:00pm-9:20pm CST Interviews
You can listen live from
your computer or phone
Log-on to WIND AM560
am560
Web Design by Emagine Multimedia, Inc.